This is one of the singularly most famous OTR episodes ever recorded, and for good reason. It’s so good and so recommended that I’ve seen OTR snobs all over the Internet claim they don’t like it simply because too many people have started to. Either way, this December 5, 1945 episode of Suspense starring Robert Taylor is one for the books, and one of the most entertaining half hours you’ll ever listen to, if not one of the scariest. Don’t worry, though. It’s a Christmas story!